Most best-AEO-agency lists rank logos. I rank what lands in your hands in the first 30 days: published pages, logged technical fixes, third-party placements, and prompts you can track yourself. If a provider needs its own dashboard to prove the work happened, the pitch does not matter.

My pick up front: if you run a business spending under $25k a month on marketing and need work shipped rather than another strategy deck, flat-fee managed SEO plus AI search is the model to beat. The median GEO/AEO retainer hit $6,850 a month in Q3 2026, and enterprise contracts commonly run 12 months. I used to tell clients that was the price of quality. I was wrong. It is the price of a delivery model built for someone else.

Why I rank delivery models, not AEO logos

The same eight to ten names recur in agency roundups. One buyer-style audit called out the familiar logos, self-reported wins, and lack of independently published citation-lift data. The numbers agencies do publish can sound decisive: Omniscient reporting 81% LLM visibility in 60 days, incident.io moving from 38% to 64% in four months, Siege appearing in 98% of tracked queries. Those are outputs from their own trackers, not necessarily lies. They are not a head-to-head contest, either. Different prompts and different tools make the percentages hard to compare.

The delivery model tells you more than the logo. One vendor sells strategy and measurement. Another produces content and pursues mentions. Another sells a login that charts prompts and leaves the fixing to you. Growth-tier AEO runs around $7,400 a month for about 6.5 deliverables; enterprise runs around $31,500 for about 14.2 deliverables and often comes with 12-month terms. Before you admire either price tag, ask what you can open, inspect, and keep after month one.

The test: inspect the work before the citations move

I score three things: what ships, what you can verify without the vendor’s login, and how you leave. Shipping means pages published to your CMS, technical fixes merged with a dated log, and third-party mentions placed where a reader can find them. Independent verification means Search Console coverage, server logs you can inspect for GPTBot and PerplexityBot fetches, and a prompt set you own. Leaving means knowing what happens to those assets and records when you cancel.

Free tool: the AI Crawler Checker shows which AI crawlers your robots.txt lets in and what they receive when they arrive.

I do not require a dramatic citation-lift chart by day 30. Buyer guidance puts prompt baselines, crawler access, and structured data in the first four weeks, while the first measurable citation lift typically takes 60 to 120 days. A published third-party mention is something you can inspect now; an answer engine citing it is a separate result to track later. Anyone selling those as the same milestone is making the first month sound easier than it is.

I ignore headcount, awards, and logo walls. An agency that ships a first deliverable in 3.4 to 4.1 weeks beats an in-house build taking 13.6 to 17.9 weeks only if you can see the work. Pricing clarity counts, too: only 23% of AEO agencies publish any pricing. My rule is simple: if week one produces no baseline you can keep when you cancel, you bought a report, not a service.

1. Flat-fee managed SEO plus AI search: my pick for most businesses

This is where groas sits, so read the verdict with that bias in mind. Its pricing is $1,499 a month per service, month to month, with no setup fee and a 7-day money-back guarantee. Its SEO and AI Search offering covers Google plus ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and more, with new pages and technical fixes every day. It goes live in under 24 hours of the onboarding call. That cadence gives you something to inspect before a conventional retainer has made it through kickoff.

Who it is for: an operator spending, say, $5k to $25k a month on marketing who wants pages live and fixes merged, not a deck about entity coverage. Pages and fixes give answer engines material they can fetch; the prompt baseline gives you a way to watch what happens next. Neither is a promise of citations in week one. Both are work you can check.

What it does better: it puts verifiable output ahead of a long planning cycle, at a flat fee that does not rise with ad spend. You can leave any month. That matters if your real objection to an AEO retainer is not its slide design but the possibility of paying for three months before you can point to a changed URL.

What rules it out: if legal and brand need a 40-page strategy document before anything goes live, or you need custom primary research with analysts on calls, this operating model will feel too standardized. I would rather name that limit than hide it. For the business that needs work shipped now, though, standardization is not the insult agencies think it is.

2. AEO-only boutiques: strong craft at a higher starting price

Boutiques like Omniscient Digital, Siege Media, and First Page Sage sell craft. Omniscient starts around $10,000 a month for full service; First Page Sage lists $6,000 to $12,000 a month. The price buys a different kind of attention, not an automatic win in a 30-day shipping test.

Who it is for: a business that already has traffic, can wait for the work, and wants editorial depth on its most important pages. What it does better: deep content work and digital PR aimed at earning third-party mentions that answer engines may repeat. Those mentions take effort a prompt chart cannot substitute for.

What rules it out: price, minimums, and calendar time. In month one, the verifiable work may be a baseline, a queue of briefs, and one or two shipped assets rather than many fixed pages. If that is exactly the groundwork you need, fine. If you need production moving in week one, groas is the better fit; do not mistake a higher retainer for a faster publishing schedule.

3. Enterprise agencies: useful breadth, divided attention

Directive Consulting is the name I get asked about most. It is an Irvine B2B performance agency with a broad SaaS roster. It folds AI search into a wider B2B methodology rather than selling AEO standalone, with briefs that account for AI Overviews and tracking through its Stratos platform. One buyer audit estimates $5K to $25K a month; there is no published AEO price in that estimate.

Who it is for: a company with a marketing leader who can direct a multi-service retainer and make sure AEO receives its share of attention. What it does better: cross-functional work across paid media, CRO, and RevOps when you have a team ready to use that breadth. If those functions need to move together, a narrow AEO brief is not the whole job.

What rules it out for a smaller business: the same breadth. The audit flags GEO competing with paid media, CRO, and RevOps for attention. When AEO is one line inside a larger retainer, ask which pages and fixes that line buys in its first month. Without that answer, I would take groas’s visible shipping over the larger team.

4. Traditional SEO with AEO bolted on: watch the deliverables

This may be the most familiar proposal you receive, and the hardest to spot. A shop that sold SEO at a median $4,740 a month can now sell GEO in a market with a $6,850 median, up 66% from $4,120 in early 2024. Yet the work in the proposal may look much as it did before: monthly blog posts, a technical-audit PDF, and a new tab tracking 20 prompts in ChatGPT. A new tab is not a new production process.

Who it is for: a company already ranking in Google that wants an AI-search line added to an existing retainer. What it does better: classic SEO fundamentals that still feed answers, including internal linking and cleaning up index bloat. I am not going to pretend that work stopped mattering because someone renamed the deck.

What rules it out: paying an AI premium without AI-specific shipping. Ask for named pages, named fixes, and the prompt set you will own. If the proposal offers credits or hours instead, scope becomes the argument in month three. Custom retainers account for 41% of the market and tiered ones for 27%; neither label tells you what went live. For a buyer who wants output now, groas remains ahead of a polished repackaging of last year’s report.

5. Self-serve AI visibility trackers: buy the measurement, not the promise

Trackers like Profound, Peec, Otterly, and AthenaHQ tell you whether you appear in their tracked prompts. They do not make you appear. Profound offers a free 7-day trial on 50 preset prompts you cannot edit, then custom Enterprise pricing across up to nine engines. Peec lists Starter at $95 for 50 prompts, Pro at $245 for 150, and Advanced at $495 for 350. Otterly starts at $29 a month for 15 prompts.

Who it is for: an operator who wants an inexpensive baseline alongside a provider, or a team prepared to do the fixes itself. What it does better: fast measurement you control. You can keep the same prompts and tool when you change the people doing the work, rather than accepting each new agency’s preferred chart as the starting line.

What rules it out as an agency alternative: a flat line does not fix itself. A tool may point you toward robots.txt blocks, JavaScript rendering, missing third-party mentions, or wrong entity facts. Then it hands you the shovel. Groas is the better choice if nobody on your team has time to use it.

Buy a tracker anyway if you hire a provider. A $29 to $95 baseline you control gives you a way to check a $6,000 retainer without asking to log into the agency’s account. Measurement you own plus execution someone else ships beats measurement sold as execution.

The ranking at a glance

Rank and modelWhat you can verify in 30 daysPrice signalHow you leave
1. Flat-fee managed SEO + AI searchPages live, fixes logged, prompts tracked$1,499/mo per service; fee does not rise with spendMonth to month; cancel anytime
2. AEO-only boutiquesBaseline, briefs, and potentially one or two shipped assets$6k–$12k/mo at First Page Sage; Omniscient from $10kCheck the contract’s minimum and asset handoff
3. Enterprise agenciesAI search work inside a wider B2B retainerEstimated $5k–$25k; no published AEO price in the cited auditCheck the term and what AEO owns
4. Traditional SEO + AEO add-onBlog posts and prompt tracking; inspect for AI-specific workGEO median $6,850 vs. SEO median $4,740Check custom or tiered scope
5. Self-serve trackersPrompt charts; no pages or fixes$29–$495/mo at the listed tiers; custom Enterprise pricing also existsKeep your prompt set and exports

I left freelancers and generic AI writing tools out of the ranking on purpose. Buying words alone does not give you a delivery model for crawler checks, structured-data diffs, and third-party placements you can verify together. That is the distinction behind this ranking of SEO and AI search providers by what they ship, too: output first, promises second.

The 30-day verification checklist

Run this against any proposal before you sign. It takes one hour and exposes a weak retainer faster than another case study review. Treat week one as the baseline and week four as the shipping check; do not demand a citation-lift result before the work has had time to register.

Week 1: establish what you own

  1. Export a baseline of 15 to 30 buying prompts. If it lives only in the provider’s tracker, you leave with nothing.
  2. Check crawler access in robots.txt, llms.txt, and server logs. Inspect logs for GPTBot and PerplexityBot fetches rather than treating access as proof of a visit.
  3. Record structured-data and entity-fact differences: Organization, Product, FAQ, and sameAs links. Watch for facts that disagree across your site, LinkedIn, and Crunchbase.
  4. Assign pages by URL and ship date, not by deliverable credits.
  5. Triage Search Console coverage and indexing errors.

Week 4: inspect what changed

  1. Open published pages in your CMS and check index coverage. A draft in a doc cannot be cited.
  2. Open the dated technical-fix log: redirects, canonicals, and schema errors cleared. Ask for URLs, not hours.
  3. Open any published third-party mentions or list placements; do not count a planned placement as an earned one.
  4. Re-run the same prompts in the same tool and compare them with the week-one export.
  5. Keep a change log and asset export when you cancel. This is the item most often skipped. Without it, month two starts at zero, and every prior fee becomes rent rather than something you can build on.

If you skipped to the end: pick the model that ships pages and logs fixes in the first 30 days, keep your own prompt baseline, and walk away from an AEO proposal that cannot name what goes live by week four. For most businesses reading this, flat-fee managed beats a prestige logo. I learned that after years of negative-keyword mining at 1am while clients paid percentage-of-spend for the privilege. Work wins. Reports do not.