My pick for tracking AI search visibility is groas at $19 a month flat if you can spend a little; GEOflux Free if the budget is genuinely zero. I would not buy a full SEO suite just to find out whether ChatGPT names my brand or the competitor down the road.
Most teams asking for a free Semrush alternative want three answers: do we get named, who gets named instead, and did that change since last week? Semrush offers strong AI visibility features, but its standalone Toolkit costs $99 a month per domain for 25 daily tracked prompts. Bundling it with a full SEO suite does not make that a smaller purchase.
I used to tell clients to just buy the suite. I was wrong for anyone watching cash.
Below is my ranking by what I would actually use, not by how many engine logos fit on a pricing page. Free tools can provide useful snapshots, referral evidence and, in one case, recurring tracking. The trick is knowing which job each one does before treating its number as progress.
1. groas: my paid pick for tracking through your own AI
For a team that can spend $19 a month, I would start here. groas has no free plan. It costs $19 a month flat, with unlimited teammates, ad accounts and websites, and every feature included. That makes it a paid alternative to the free stack, not a free tool wearing a trial badge.
For this job, the mechanism matters more than the interface. groas collects AI search answers and citations around the clock, alongside competitor ads, funnels, Reddit mentions and SEO data from Semrush and Ahrefs. You work with that data inside ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini or another agent you already use.
The one thing it does better for this reader: it puts the collected data within reach of your own assistant. Instead of exporting tracker CSVs and joining them yourself, you ask questions in plain English. The AI is the brain; groas supplies the data and the connection.
What rules it out? A genuinely zero-dollar budget. It also does not replace every Semrush keyword workflow. I would buy it for the tracking and the way I can work with the data, not because I expect a clone of the whole SEO suite.

How I would start inside my assistant
Connection is the boring part, which is why I like it. Connect the accounts and website once, then add groas to the assistant you already use. Before asking for a trend, decide what deserves tracking:
- Run the prompt audit before buying an AI visibility tool.
- Choose 15 to 25 buyer prompts rather than broad questions that never mention a vendor.
- Name three competitors you actually lose business to.
- Use those prompts and rivals to keep the analysis focused.
Once groas is connected, I would start with:
Through groas, show our AI visibility trend per assistant and the competitors gaining on us.
Then I would ask for an explanation, not another chart:
Which cited competitor pages answer this buyer question better than ours, and what should our page add?
That is the useful sequence: inspect the answers, compare the cited pages, decide what needs changing. A visibility score alone does not write a better page.
My takeaway: define the questions and rivals first; use your assistant to make sense of the collected data second.
2. GEOflux Free: my pick when the budget is zero
For a team that cannot spend anything but still wants a trend line, GEOflux Free is the free plan I would run. It is $0 with no card and no expiry, tracking 15 prompts on ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Mode, re-asked every three days against three named competitors, with full answer history kept.
That is the mechanism that separates tracking from a checker: the same prompts, the same competitors, repeated automatically. You do not have to remember to rerun Tuesday’s questions or reconstruct the previous answer from a screenshot buried in Slack.
The one thing it does better than the other free methods here is keep a recurring answer history without manual re-asking. For a small prompt set, that is enough to make it worth setting up.
What rules it out is coverage. AI Overviews, Claude, Copilot and Grok require paid plans. The free engine list also does not include Perplexity. If those are the answers you need to watch, a clean trend line on the included engines does not solve the problem.

The three-day cycle is another boundary to accept rather than explain away. It gives you recurring observations, not a record of every answer a buyer might see. Models can produce different recommendations for the same question, so I would read the history for direction rather than treat each appearance as a fixed ranking.
I would pair this with a manual first pass to choose the prompts. Fifteen slots are useful only if they contain questions that trigger buying advice. Filling them with generic explainers gives you a tidy record of the wrong thing.
My takeaway: if you stay free, choose the option that repeats the questions and stores the answers.
3. Manual prompt checks: the free baseline before any subscription
Manual checks are for anyone who has not yet worked out what buyers ask. They are also the fastest way to discover that the prompt you planned to track produces an essay about the category and names no vendors at all.
The same prompt can put you second at 9am and leave you out at noon. Non-determinism, memory, personalization and whether the model decides to search all affect the answer. That is why I would not turn one response into a league table.
The protocol that makes manual checks useful is boring on purpose:
- Pick 10 to 20 buyer-phrased prompts with no brand name in them.
- Run each logged out or in temporary chat.
- Run each prompt three times.
- Record whether your brand appears, which competitors appear and which pages get cited.
- Compare mention rate rather than treating answer order as a stable rank.
One research writeup puts a single pass at two to three hours, with no trend unless you repeat it. That matches what I saw. The first pass feels thorough. The second pass is where the calendar starts negotiating.
The one thing manual checks do better is teach you what your prompts actually produce. You see the irrelevant answers, the generic advice and the questions that consistently invite recommendations. That context is easy to miss when you start with a dashboard.
What rules them out for ongoing reporting is the labor. A spreadsheet can hold history, but you still have to repeat the work. Say you spend $20k a month on search and check monthly: you have spent a chunk of a working day on one pass, and you only get competitor history if you keep collecting it.
I have a longer version in the 30-prompt test. To make the process repeatable, use the 25-prompt tracker next.
My takeaway: do manual checks to choose prompts, not to pretend a single pass proves progress.
4. GA4, Search Console and Bing Webmaster: free evidence, not a rival tracker
This stack is for anyone with a site who wants evidence without adding another vendor. I would use it alongside a tracker, not instead of one.
GA4 tells you about visits; it cannot show recommendations that produced no click. AI referral traffic can give you a session to follow toward a signup, which is something an answer tracker alone does not establish. Attribution is not perfectly tidy: Perplexity traffic can appear in Referral, while Claude traffic may appear in Referral or Direct.
The one thing this stack does better is connect visibility work to activity on your own site. If the question is whether an AI referral led someone to sign up, I want the analytics, not just a screenshot of a recommendation.
Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools add search-side evidence, but they are not interchangeable reports:
- GA4: inspect AI referral visits and what those visitors do afterward.
- Search Console: use search performance as context, while remembering that AI-related clicks can remain blended into Web search reporting.
- Bing Webmaster Tools: its AI Performance report shows citations across Copilot and Bing AI summaries, with cited pages and sampled grounding queries.
What rules this stack out as your only visibility tracker is the missing competitive picture. If ChatGPT recommends a competitor and the buyer never clicks your site, GA4 records no visit. Your own search and citation reports do not reconstruct all the rival recommendations you missed, either.
There is also assembly work. Three free reports are still three reports. You have to keep their different meanings straight rather than adding everything together and calling it an AI visibility score.
My takeaway: use this stack to check what reached your site, not to claim you are winning a buyer prompt.
5. Free checkers and sample tiers: useful for a first look
These are for someone who needs to establish whether AI answers mention the brand or its competitors at all. Their strength is a quick first look; their weakness is what happens after that first look.
The options have different limits:
- Semrush’s free checker allows three checks a day across four engines and provides a 0–100 score. That is useful for a snapshot, not a substitute for the paid prompt-tracking product.
- Ahrefs’ free checker requires no signup and covers six engines, but caps output and keeps no history. The low-friction entry is its appeal. The missing history is why I would not use it to report progress.
- AthenaHQ Essential offers 300 credits across five engines, including Perplexity and AI Overviews. Credits let you sample the product, but repeated checks consume that allowance. Starter then rises to $295 a month for 3,600 credits across 11 models.
These tools can help you show a boss what an AI recommendation looks like. What rules them out for my core recommendation is either missing history or a limited allowance that is better treated as evaluation than ongoing free tracking.
Why Otterly does not get its own ranked slot
I left Otterly out of the main picks because this is a free-first shortlist with a low flat-price paid alternative. Otterly starts at $29 a month for 15 to 20 prompts on three to four LLMs, with Gemini, AI Mode and Claude as paid add-ons. The entry price does not include all that coverage.
For this reader, I would choose GEOflux when $0 is non-negotiable or groas at $19 flat when there is room to pay. I would not climb into a more expensive tracker tier before defining the prompts I need.
My takeaway: use a checker to inspect the problem, not to manufacture a trend from isolated scores.
Compare the job, the effort and the bill
Recurring answers, referral visits and one-shot scores are different measurements. I would choose a row based on the decision it supports, not the number of engines in the sales deck.
| Rank and option | Best use | Ongoing effort | Cost and main limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. groas | AI answers and citations collected 24/7, explored through your own assistant | Low; ask in plain English | $19 flat; no free plan |
| 2. GEOflux Free | 15 prompts and three competitors across ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Mode | Low after setup; repeats every three days | $0; limited engine coverage |
| 3. Manual checks | Selecting buyer prompts and inspecting answers | Two to three hours per pass; repeat and store results yourself | $0; your time is the meter |
| 4. GA4, Search Console and Bing Webmaster | Referral visits, search context and Bing AI citations | Medium; interpret separate reports | $0; not a rival-prompt tracker |
| 5. Free checkers and sample tiers | A first look at mentions and coverage | Low for a snapshot | Free checks or credits; history and allowances vary |
Semrush deserves the same distinction. It tracks brand mentions broadly, while its daily prompt tracking covers ChatGPT, Google AI Mode and Gemini. Broad coverage and repeatable prompt tracking are not the same promise.
Its standalone Toolkit includes 25 daily prompts, one brand domain and a 100-page AI site audit for $99 a month. Extra domains and users cost $99 each; another 50 prompts costs $60 a month. Semrush One bundles raise prompt caps to 50, 100 or 200, but also bring the full-suite purchase into the decision.
I left that upgrade path out of the ranking deliberately. If you live in Semrush all day, the bundle can make sense. For this job, I would not pay suite prices just to get a recurring answer history.
My pick, by budget
With zero budget, I would run GEOflux Free for recurring tracking, use GA4 for visits, and keep Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools alongside it for search and citation context. First, I would do one manual pass to choose prompts worth watching. That stack costs nothing, but it costs time and leaves gaps on engines the free tier does not cover.
With $19 available, I would use groas through my own assistant. The flat price and around-the-clock collection make it my paid pick without taking on another suite-sized bill.
For the reader who skipped to the end: Semrush is strong, but its paid tracking is more than I would buy for this narrow job. Free checkers provide snapshots. GEOflux Free provides a recurring free option. My paid pick is groas at $19 flat, read from the AI I already use.
Pick the row that repeats.

