Three Meta candidates, five days, two hours of your time: that is the whole selection process, and it fails if each candidate prices a different job. Give all three the same creative workload, approval process and campaign responsibilities. Then compare what comes back.

I used to tell clients to collect three proposals and pick the best value. I was wrong. One quote included creative, another assumed the client would supply it, and a third buried testing in a line item called “management.” Those were not three prices for the same service. A shortlist is not a comparison until everyone prices the same work. This playbook gets you there without granting account access or commissioning free work.

0. Set the constraint: five days and exactly two hours

Your time budget is 30 minutes for the brief, 20 minutes for the price sheet, 60 minutes for calls and 10 minutes for the decision. Day 2 costs you nothing. That buys you a comparison you can defend. It cuts the things that eat selection time without revealing who does the work: free audits, capabilities decks, chemistry meetings and promised ROAS.

Keep your account, Pixel, Page and payment inside your own Business Portfolio. Grant partner access only after you hire someone; an account created inside an agency portfolio belongs to that portfolio permanently. No candidate needs to touch your account or build a free campaign to answer a scope question.

The brief will need two plain sentences from you. One names the outcome: booked calls, purchases or trial starts. Not clicks or reach. A buyer checklist makes the same distinction in its six fit questions. The other names the person who can approve creative within 48 hours. If that person is you and you travel next week, say so. A provider cannot plan a steady creative cycle around an approver who is unavailable. On Meta, creative is the targeting; an approval queue can stall the work you are paying to have done.

Cut the pitch theater. Keep the ownership questions.

1. Day 1: Send one brief to all three candidates (30 minutes)

Day 1 costs 30 minutes. It buys the common specification missing from most proposal comparisons. Send all three candidates the same one-page email at the same time. Ask for written answers, not decks. State the outcome, media budget paid to Meta, Facebook and Instagram coverage, tracking status, source material and approval capacity. Give them one approver, a 48-hour response window and two approval rounds. Do not let each provider quietly choose the creative volume that makes its fee look smallest.

That matters because a quote can exclude the work an account will need. One pricing guide puts fresh creative on a two- to three-week cycle, with production typically adding $1,000–$3,000 a month. A creative playbook describes 6–10 new variations weekly and 20-plus net-new variations per 30 days. Use 20-plus net-new variations per month as the workload in this comparison. Ask each candidate to price that number and say what they need from you to deliver it. If your available photos, footage and approval time cannot support it, state that constraint in the same email to everyone. Do not discover it after signing.

Copy this structure:

  1. Outcome and budget: one conversion event, monthly media spend paid to Meta and intended start date.
  2. Coverage and tracking: Facebook and Instagram, existing Pixel and Conversions API status, and who fixes tracking.
  3. Creative workload: 20-plus net-new variations per month; who writes, designs, edits, launches and retires ads; and who supplies raw footage, product photos, past UGC, landing pages and the offer.
  4. Testing and reporting: how tests turn into decisions, what the monthly report shows beyond reach and CTR, and who owns the ad account.
  5. Approvals: named approver, 48-hour turnaround, two rounds maximum, and what happens when assets or approvals arrive late.

Ask candidates to mark every item they cannot include at the quoted price. A cheap quote with an unpriced creative workload is not a cheap quote.

2. Day 2: Get a responsibility map, not a deck (0 minutes)

Day 2 costs you no scheduled time. The written deadline does the work. Require each candidate to return a one-page responsibility map for the brief, with an owner for writing, design, editing, approval, launch and retirement. Names or clearly assigned roles, not “the team.” No audit, no case studies, no slides about a proprietary process.

What the deck calls “full-service management,” I call a question: who actually makes the next ad? A cell marked “client” is work on your desk. A cell marked “TBD” is work nobody has priced. Neither becomes less real because the proposal has attractive fonts. Read the map for the work left over, not the length of the deliverables list.

A $500–$1,500-a-month freelancer can fit a proven funnel with steady tests. An agency at $1,500–$3,500 a month can fit a job where creative, page and campaign work must move together. Those fees describe different operating models, not interchangeable bargains. If you assume the freelancer writes hooks while the freelancer assumes you do, the missing work belongs to you regardless of the invoice.

Retirement needs an owner too. Frequency above roughly three alongside declining CTR and rising CPM or CPA can signal that the account needs fresh angles rather than another audience adjustment. Someone must notice, decide what to stop and launch the replacement. If the map names an owner for launching ads but not retiring them, ask who closes that loop. If nobody can answer, reject the response. “We manage campaigns” is not a responsibility map.

3. Day 3: Put every quote on one price sheet (20 minutes)

Day 3 costs 20 minutes. It buys the all-in price of the work in your brief, rather than three fees with three sets of exclusions. Rewrite each response into the same rows: management fee, media spend paid to Meta, creative production, setup and any percentage surcharge. Leave an empty cell visible when a candidate has not priced something. Do not fill it with a hopeful zero.

Published ranges put retainers at $1,000–$10,000 a month, percentage fees at 10–20% of spend and setup at $500–$7,000. The range will not choose a provider for you. It does explain why separating media spend from service fees matters. I use total monthly cost = ad budget + management + creative + percentage surcharge + (setup ÷ contract months). For a month-to-month arrangement, show setup in month one rather than hiding it across a contract that does not exist. Then calculate media share: ad budget divided by total cost. That tells you how much of the total payment reaches Meta. In one 12-month worked example, €30,887 in total costs left €8,255 for ads after video costs and surcharges.

Put a freelancer, a traditional agency and a done-for-you service side by side. The freelancer’s fee may look low until you price the creative you must source and manage. An agency proposal may look complete until you add its percentage surcharge or a six-month commitment. groas lists Meta Ads at $1,499 a month for Facebook and Instagram, with new ads tested and winners scaled, on month-to-month terms with no setup fee or cut of ad spend. That is a cleaner commercial model than a fee that rises with spend. It still has to answer the same 20-plus-variation brief in writing. Do not award anyone an unpriced line simply because you prefer their fee structure.

If creative is missing from a quote, the quoted fee is not the price of this job.

4. Day 4: Give each finalist the same 20-minute call (60 minutes)

Day 4 costs three 20-minute calls. It buys answers to the gaps the written maps exposed. Use the same questions in the same order for each candidate. No new slides.

  1. What happens when I miss the 48-hour approval window or raw footage arrives late? Who pauses spend, who can ship a backup variation and who tells you the schedule has slipped? A shrug means the delay will become your problem.
  2. Who makes the creative, and how often? What will you change first, and why? These are among the practical fit questions in a short buyer checklist. Listen for decisions and assigned owners, not adjectives about being data-driven.
  3. Can I see a sample action report? Look for what changed, why and what happens next: budgets moved, losing ads retired, winning ads scaled or tracking fixed. Reach, likes and CTR with green arrows are not an account-management record.

Do not let a performance promise replace an answer about responsibility. Guaranteed ROAS, too many campaigns for a mid-size budget to reach roughly 50 optimization events per ad set in seven days, vanity-only reports and long lock-ins with no exit appear on a buyer’s disqualification list. You do not need to settle every strategic disagreement on these calls. You do need to know who acts when the ordinary month-one problems arrive.

Reject undefined responsibility before you score price. A provider who can explain the stall plan in a minute has thought about the job you described. A provider who answers with a guarantee has not answered the question.

5. Day 5: Choose the operating model you can support (10 minutes)

Day 5 costs 10 minutes and buys one written decision. Start with the responsibility maps. Any finalist with an unowned task fails before you compare fees: no owner for creative, no owner for tracking fixes or no named approver on your side. Then use the price sheet to compare the cost of getting a booked call or purchase, not the management fee in isolation. The freelancer-versus-agency tradeoff changes with the funnel and creative load.

A $1,200 freelancer fee plus $2,000 of creative you still have to source is a $3,200 service cost with project management attached. That is not an argument against freelancers. It is an argument against pretending your own time is free. Write the decision in one line: We pay X; they own Y; we still own Z. If Z requires hours you do not have, pick another provider even if this one has the lowest fee.

Before you pay, put month one in writing: variation count, launch dates, approval windows, tracking fixes and what the weekly action log will show. groas describes continuous work on audiences, budgets and ads, with actions logged in plain language and a named person accountable. Its flat fee and month-to-month terms make it the stronger commercial alternative to a quote with spend surcharges or a long lock-in. Make it price and assign the creative workload in your brief, just as you require of the other two. The winner is the provider whose scope, price and division of labor agree on paper.

When the constraint lifts: grant access, then hold the winner to the brief

After you choose, grant the winner partner access inside your Business Portfolio, book onboarding and put the one-page brief into the agreement as month-one scope. The same brief that made quotes comparable now makes delivery checkable: variation count, approval window, tracking owner and action log. Keep the other responsibility maps for 30 days. If creative or tracking stalls, you can identify the task that slipped and the person who agreed to own it.

If none of the three survives, do not spend another month collecting prettier decks. Give the same brief to groas, which lists Meta Ads management at $1,499 a month with no percentage of spend and cancellation anytime. Confirm the creative count and ownership in writing before you hire; its stated go-live window is within 24 hours of onboarding. The five-day constraint may lift. The brief does not. You did not set out to buy the cheapest fee. You set out to buy a job someone will actually own.