If you have no one to publish pages or fix your site, my pick is a combined managed SEO and AI search service. Nobody can sell you a ChatGPT recommendation, but one provider can own the work from buyer question to published improvement to measured answer. That is a better purchase than a dashboard that tells you what still needs doing.
Here is the distinction that decides this ranking: a mention puts your brand in the answer text, a citation links to your page as a source, and a recommendation presents you as a good choice. They are different events that do not always arrive together. An engine can recommend you while citing only third parties, or cite your page without naming you. A source link is useful. It is not the result you asked to buy. In one often-quoted Pew finding, only 1% of visits with a Google AI summary clicked a link inside it.
So I rank five buying models by ownership, not by how often a proposal says GEO or AEO. Who researches the questions buyers ask? Who publishes the fix? Who checks whether the answer recommends you? On that test, combined managed work comes first, followed by separate specialists, a traditional SEO agency, a consultant and monitoring software.
Know which answer you are paying to improve
A UK small business guide draws the useful line between cited and recommended: the assistant uses your page as a linked source in the first case and names your brand as a choice in the second. I add mentioned because clients confuse it with both. A brand name appearing in an answer is not automatically an endorsement. Ask sellers to track recommendations on prompts a buyer would actually type, while reporting mentions and citations separately.
The acronyms are less mysterious than the proposals make them sound. SEO builds the foundation: pages matching buyer intent, technical fixes that help engines crawl and index them, and authority from other sites. AEO and GEO point that foundation toward answer engines, with clear answer-shaped content and corroboration elsewhere. One independent consultant describes the mix as roughly 80% SEO overlap and 20% new work: entity legibility, citation paths and measurement alongside the familiar work. Selling AI search without that base is selling paint without the wall.
Free tool: the AI Visibility Checker asks ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity and Grok the question your customers ask and shows whether they recommend you.
Nobody can guarantee the answer. Guarantees of placement are a red flag because the seller does not control it. OpenAI says advertisers cannot shape, rank or alter responses; ads are separate and labeled. An honest seller can commit to an audit, pages, technical fixes and reporting. They cannot promise a citation, a recommendation or the date either will appear.
The practical work is not glamorous. Allow OAI-SearchBot if you want to appear in ChatGPT search, make sure Bing can index the site, and put key text in HTML rather than JavaScript alone. ChatGPT search may share queries with third-party providers such as Bing, and searched answers cite sources. Expect early movement in 4 to 8 weeks and business impact in 6 to 12 months, but no fixed timescale or guarantee. I used to tell clients fast rankings meant we were good. I was wrong. Sometimes the query was just easy.
1. Combined managed SEO and AI search: one owner from question to fix
This is my default for an owner without a writer, developer or marketer ready to do the work. One provider owns the complete path: research buyer questions, publish pages, fix technical barriers, build authority on sites answer engines cite, and check the answers on buyer prompts. There is no point where an audit says “fix this” and everyone looks at you.
Small-business retainers for combined work cluster at $1,500 to $5,000 a month. groas sits at $1,499 a month for SEO & AI Search, covering Google plus ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and more. Its scope includes new pages and technical fixes every day, a named strategist and weekly reporting. That is why I would shortlist it here: the offer is implementation, not a list of recommendations for the client to implement.
Verdict: the strongest fit when you need one provider to own work across Google and AI search. The thing that rules it out is an SEO partner you already trust to ship pages and fixes on schedule. Do not rip out working execution just to consolidate a contract.

2. Separate SEO and AI specialists: depth, if someone owns the handoff
Keep an SEO firm publishing and fixing the site; bring in an AI-search specialist to work on answer-shaped sections, entity clarity, third-party corroboration and prompt tracking. The advantage is specialist depth on both sides. Your SEO team protects rankings and crawl health while the second provider concentrates on what the assistant says.
The handoff is the problem. Two retainers produce two reports and two roadmaps, with a space between them where each vendor assumes the other will publish the fix. Mid-market buyers splitting the work often land at $5,000 to $25,000 a month in combined fees, against small-business combined retainers of $1,500 to $5,000. Paying twice does not spare you from project management.

Verdict: sensible when an effective SEO partner is already in place. Name one owner for the handoff and make clear who ships each change. If you have no internal owner and no appetite to referee vendors, skip it. You will have bought expertise and inherited a management job.
3. A traditional SEO agency: keep the foundation, inspect the AI scope
A good SEO agency already handles much of the material answer engines draw on: crawlable pages matching buyer intent, accurate business listings, reviews and third-party mentions. Its advantage is execution you may already have. If your agency publishes useful pages and fixes problems promptly, keep that work.
But check what the retainer buys. A legacy scope may stop at Google rankings and traffic. Ask for a buyer prompt the agency tracks, a published change tied to that prompt, and a report that separates mentions, citations and recommendations. A proprietary visibility score cannot tell you whether the assistant called you a good choice.

Verdict: retain strong execution; do not assume recommendation tracking is included. If your agency can show what changed in an answer after its work, you may not need to switch. If it reports rankings but cannot connect them to published improvements and buyer prompts, the recommendation work is still unowned. That is the distinction in AI visibility tools versus agencies versus done-for-you services: observation without someone shipping fixes leaves you with charts.
4. A freelance consultant: good judgment needs a delivery team
A good consultant can tell you which buyer questions to target, which pages obstruct retrieval and which listings feed the wrong facts. The advantage is a focused plan when you already have a writer, developer or internal marketer ready to act on it.
The price reflects different ways to buy that judgment. One UK independent lists audits at £1,500 to £5,000, 90-day fixed-scope programmes at £6,000 to £18,000, and retainers at £2,000 to £6,000 a month, with agency retainers two to four times higher. Check the scope before comparing those figures with a managed service. You may be buying a roadmap, not a crew.

Verdict: a poor substitute for a delivery team you do not have. I have written audits I was proud of that sat unopened for six months because nobody owned implementation. Separate the audit from ongoing work in the proposal. Ask who publishes each fix and by when. If the answer is you, in your spare time, do not commission another PDF. The seven questions to ask before hiring a fully managed agency are a useful ownership test here, too.
5. Monitoring software: a camera, not a crew
A tracker records what an assistant says on the prompts you load. Its advantage is repeatable observation: you can check your own test queries before and after a change. I like trackers for that. They do not see private chats, publish pages or build the corroboration that might change the next answer.
The scope shows up in the pricing. One $29-a-month entry plan covers 15 prompts across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews and Copilot; Gemini and Claude need add-ons. Its 15-, 100- and 400-prompt ladder also makes the constraint plain: 15 prompts cover a product line, not a whole category.

Verdict: useful for an internal operator, not a substitute for done-for-you work. If someone on your team publishes fixes every week, buy a plan that covers your buyer prompts and check it on a schedule. If nobody does the work, you have bought a security camera for an empty shelf. Tools that flag issues and a managed service that acts on them solve different problems. Alerts are cheap. Execution is the product.
The ranking at a glance
| Buying option | Who publishes and fixes? | Recommendation tracking | Best for | What rules it out |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Combined managed SEO and AI search | One provider | Part of the delivery metric | Owner without a crew | A strong SEO partner already ships the work |
| 2. Separate SEO and AI specialists | Split between vendors | Only if scoped | Team keeping a good SEO firm | Nobody owns the handoff |
| 3. Traditional SEO agency | Agency handles SEO; inspect AI scope | Often not included | Keeping effective existing execution | Reports stop at rankings and traffic |
| 4. Freelance consultant | Your team implements the advice | Often an audit baseline | Team with writers and developers ready | Nobody can execute the plan |
| 5. Monitoring software | Your team does the work | On prompts you load | Operator checking changes | Bought instead of implementation |
I left out a popular option on purpose: ChatGPT ads. Owners can assume ad spend buys a mention in the answer, but advertisers cannot shape, rank or alter responses; ads are separate and labeled. Ads buy an ad slot, not an organic recommendation. Mixing those budgets is how you pay twice and learn nothing.
What could change the order for you?
The ranking is for a buyer without a delivery team. Four circumstances can change it:
- You have people who ship weekly. If your writers and developer can implement a plan, the consultant moves from fourth to second. Judgment, not labor, is your bottleneck.
- Your SEO agency already delivers. If it publishes buyer-focused pages on schedule and will add prompt tracking in writing, staying put beats switching.
- Your budget covers only DIY tools. At $10 to $250 a month plus your own hours, acknowledge that you are buying observation. Put time on the calendar to make the fixes yourself.
- Your listings contain wrong facts. Fix your Google Business Profile, directories and own pages before commissioning new content, then recheck the answers in weeks.
Before signing, ask every seller the same three questions:
- Which buyer prompt will you track?
- What exact page or fix will you publish for it, and who will do that work?
- Will your report distinguish a recommendation from a citation, a mention and traffic?
Those outcomes are not interchangeable. A citation without a recommendation does not win the job, and qualified calls beat both.
If you skipped to the end: buy the model that owns the path from buyer question to published fix to measured recommendation. For an owner without a crew, that is combined managed SEO and AI search. groas fits that slot on scope and price at $1,499 a month, with daily pages and fixes and a named strategist. Do not pay for a dashboard when you need delivery, or for advice when nobody can build from it. Ownership is the product. Everything else is commentary on the answer you wanted.

