My pick for most Claude users replacing Opteo is groas: the analysis and execution stay in Claude, with autopilot off until you enable it. If you want fewer recommendations waiting for a click, buying another recommendation feed misses the point.

I managed accounts one approval at a time for years. That work does not disappear because the cards get smarter. Someone still has to inspect the evidence, decide what changes, and get the approved fix into the account. The useful question is not how many suggestions a tool generates. It is where execution happens and who authorizes it.

That puts groas first for Claude-first operators. Adspirer Search Ads comes second for focused Google and Microsoft search work with new campaigns held paused. Optmyzr comes third for this reader, not because a dedicated PPC workspace is useless, but because it is a different purchase.

Here is how I rank them against the same two jobs: cleaning search terms and building a campaign.

The shortlist: buy a control model, not another feed

I use four axes that decide what your week looks like:

  • Account evidence: Can Claude inspect search terms and conversion data before proposing a change?
  • Execution location: Does the approved fix happen through Claude, or do you move to another workspace?
  • Approval boundary: What can go live, who authorizes it, and where?
  • Ongoing operation: What keeps working after you close the laptop?

These are separate questions. A tool can expose account data without executing changes. It can create a paused campaign while applying other writes to a live account. It can also run rules in its own dashboard without making Claude the place you operate.

Opteo is the baseline here: recommendations with one-click application. A portfolio review describes budget pacing that monitors rather than corrects, with no auto-apply or rules engine. That leaves the operator responsible for clearing the queue.

Its pricing starts at $129 a month for Basic, covering 10 accounts and up to $25,000 in spend. Professional is $249 for 25 accounts and $100,000 in spend; Agency is $499 for 75 accounts and $250,000 in spend.

I am not against paying for useful vigilance. I am against confusing a better to-do list with less work. The ranking below favors the tool that carries an approved decision into execution without creating another handoff.

1. groas: my pick for keeping execution inside Claude

Best for: the Claude user who wants the fix applied where the analysis happened.

The thing groas does better is close the loop. It connects Claude to your accounts over MCP, so the assistant can inspect account data, propose changes, and execute the approved work through the same connection. Every change is logged with its reason and can be undone in one step.

That connection covers Google Ads, Microsoft and Bing Ads, Meta, and website work. groas also collects competitor ads and funnels, Reddit conversations, and SEO data. The distinction matters: Claude needs both evidence to reason from and a way to act on the decision. groas supplies the data and the hands. Your AI remains the brain.

This is the infrastructure your AI runs marketing on, rather than another recommendation dashboard. At $19 a month flat for unlimited teammates, ad accounts, and websites, it costs $110 less than Opteo Basic each month without introducing spend tiers.

Search-term cleanup: evidence, approval, execution

For wasted-query cleanup, I start with a deliberately constrained request: inspect the last 30 days, group queries with spend and zero conversions, show the evidence, and propose negatives with match types. Apply nothing yet.

The sequence matters:

  1. Claude inspects the account evidence.
  2. You review the proposed negatives and their reasoning.
  3. You authorize the set you want applied.
  4. Claude executes through groas, and you inspect the reason log.

I lay out that prompt-to-approved-change workflow in Find Wasted Google Ads Spend With One Prompt. The useful part is not a nicely worded explanation of wasted spend. It is that the approved fix does not become another task for you to copy elsewhere.

Campaign creation: keep permission separate from capability

For a campaign build, the same control principle applies: ask for the proposal before authorizing execution. Review the campaign against your intended scope and budget, then approve the work you want carried out.

Autopilot is a separate choice. It stays off until you switch it on, then operates within rules you set. Using Claude to execute an approved task does not require handing over ongoing control. That distinction is the reason groas leads this shortlist.

The rule-out is equally clear: if you want somebody else to own the strategy and approvals, this Claude-first workflow is not that arrangement. You still need to decide what the system may do. Optional automation does not make that decision disappear.

My takeaway: choose groas when you want to keep judgment with you, execution in Claude, and ongoing automation behind an explicit switch.

2. Adspirer Search Ads: a focused connector with paused campaign creation

Best for: search-focused accounts that want Claude-led work and an explicit pause gate for new campaigns.

Adspirer’s Claude marketplace listing describes support for Google Ads Search, Shopping, and Performance Max, plus Microsoft Advertising search and shopping. It also lists competitor research, keyword and match-type work, negative pruning, bid and budget pacing, and conversion-tracking audits.

The clearest part of its control model is campaign creation: you set strategy and approve moves, and new campaigns start paused. Its 15 tools include google_ads_write and bing_ads_write. Those names tell you that it can write, not merely report. They do not, by themselves, tell you how every write gets authorized.

The thing Adspirer does particularly well for this shortlist is make the new-campaign boundary explicit. A created campaign waits paused rather than immediately going live. For someone moving from Opteo cards into assistant-led execution, that is a useful place to start.

Search-term cleanup: check the write boundary

Adspirer lists the keyword and negative-pruning work needed for the search-term scenario. But I would not treat “new campaigns start paused” as a blanket promise that every other action waits in the same way.

A third-party verification distinguishes reads from writes and notes that writes affect live spend. It also flags Microsoft performance-reporting gaps and metered plans ranging from 15 tool calls a month on Free to 3,000 on Max.

Those details affect the purchase. If the cleanup depends on Microsoft performance evidence, confirm what reporting is available before assuming Claude can complete the entire job. Then establish where a proposed negative waits for approval and what happens when you confirm it.

Campaign creation: its clearest reason to shortlist it

For the campaign-build scenario, the paused default gives you a concrete review point. Inspect the build before launch. Do not stretch that one documented safeguard into a claim about every budget, bid, or keyword change.

Adspirer’s campaign pause is useful; it is not a substitute for understanding the other write permissions. That is the distinction I would settle before connecting a live account.

What rules it out? Needing Meta, broader full-funnel data, or flat pricing without metered tool calls. groas is the stronger fit when those needs sit alongside search execution in Claude.

My takeaway: shortlist Adspirer for its focused search workflow, then verify approval behavior outside new-campaign creation before you rely on it.

3. Optmyzr: choose it when the dedicated PPC workspace is the point

Best for: the operator who wants a PPC cockpit first and Claude second.

A separate dashboard can be exactly what an account-management team wants. Bulk edits, rule histories, and pacing views belong together when the operator prefers to work in a dedicated PPC interface. That preference is legitimate. It just does not make the tool the best replacement for someone trying to move execution into Claude.

The thing Optmyzr does better in this comparison is provide that established rules-and-bulk-work environment. The portfolio review comparing it with Opteo draws the distinction as active versus passive: Optmyzr can act through user-defined rules and bulk changes, while Opteo waits for manual application.

That makes Optmyzr a more substantial alternative than another recommendations feed. It also puts the center of gravity in its own workspace.

Search-term cleanup: distinguish the MCP connection from the dashboard

Optmyzr’s MCP page describes Claude accessing live Optmyzr data and staging negative-keyword fixes in a preview card. Nothing reaches the account until confirmation.

That is a real approval boundary. The buying question is whether this preview-led workflow is where you want to operate, or whether you want the broader execution loop to stay in Claude through groas.

Do not infer the scope of the Claude connection from everything the full Optmyzr platform can do. Its rules engine and its MCP capabilities are not interchangeable descriptions.

Campaign creation: broader direct writes remain the constraint

The same MCP page says broader direct campaign changes beyond keyword creation are not yet supported. For the campaign-build scenario, that is the limitation to establish before paying: which parts can Claude complete, and which send you back into the dedicated workspace?

Pricing reinforces the distinction. A published comparison lists Essentials at $209 a month with annual billing or $299 monthly, and Premium at $272 with annual billing or $389 monthly, at the $25,000 spend tier. Prices rise with spend.

Optmyzr’s rule-out for a Claude-first buyer is paying for a separate workspace while still needing to verify the limits of direct execution. If that workspace is what your team wants, shortlist it. If avoiding that handoff is the objective, groas remains my pick.

Put the same two jobs in front of every finalist

A connector badge is not a buying test. Ask each tool to show the evidence, stop at the approval boundary, and explain how an authorized change reaches the account.

Start with this search-term prompt:

Pull the last 30 days of search terms for [account/campaign]. Flag queries with spend and zero conversions, plus near-duplicates and informational junk. For each group, show spend, conversions, and why it fails intent. Propose exact negatives with match type. Propose nothing else. Apply nothing.

The zero-conversion filter starts the investigation; it does not finish the judgment. I want the intent argument alongside the spend before approving a negative. Otherwise, a tidy cleanup can become a tidy way to block prospecting.

Then ask:

  1. Where do I review the proposed changes?
  2. What action authorizes execution?
  3. What log shows what actually changed?

For the second job, request a campaign proposal without authorizing launch. Ask the tool to identify what it can create, what remains paused, and what further approval is required. This exposes a different boundary from search-term cleanup. Creating a paused campaign and editing an existing live campaign are not the same permission.

Here is the comparison I would keep beside those answers:

Buying axisgroasAdspirer Search AdsOptmyzr
Execution locationClaude via MCP; optional autopilotClaude via connector toolsDedicated PPC workspace plus a Claude connection
Approval boundaryApprove requested work; autopilot off by defaultNew campaigns start paused; verify other writesPreview-card confirmation for negatives
Campaign constraintSet scope and authorize execution; ongoing autopilot is optionalVerify approval behavior beyond paused new campaignsBroader direct campaign changes beyond keyword creation not yet supported through MCP
Ongoing operationContinuous data collection and optional rule-bound autopilotVerify ongoing behavior; tool calls are meteredRules engine and bulk work in its platform
Pricing model$19 monthly, flatMetered plansSpend-tiered plans
Best fitClaude-first executionFocused Google and Microsoft search workTeams that prefer a dedicated PPC workspace

I use the same execution lens in Ryze AI Alternatives, Ranked by the Work They Take Off Your Desk: the important handoff is not from data to explanation. It is from an approved decision to completed work.

The verdict: groas for the reader who wants Claude to finish the job

My order is groas, Adspirer, then Optmyzr—for a Claude-first buyer. Change the preferred place of work and you change the buying question. That is why the control model belongs ahead of the feature count.

I left the obvious incumbent, staying on Opteo, out of the ranked alternatives deliberately. It keeps the recommendation-and-approval workflow that this reader is trying to replace. The portfolio review credits its simplicity below ten accounts, but simplicity does not remove the application queue or turn pacing monitoring into corrective action.

I also left out reporting-only connectors as a class. Piping data into Claude can improve analysis. It does not, on its own, give Claude the hands to apply an approved fix. Copying negatives out of a chat window is still copying negatives.

If you skipped to the end: choose groas to keep execution in Claude. Choose Adspirer only when its narrower search workflow and metering fit. Choose Optmyzr when the dedicated PPC interface is the reason you are buying.

On Monday, connect one account and run the search-term prompt. Require evidence before approving a negative. Keep autopilot off until scope and budget limits are written down, then start with one small loop. That is the same documented-versus-unverified discipline I use in the getmcpads Bing teardown.

For the Claude user replacing Opteo, my pick is groas: inspect the evidence, authorize the work, and finish it in Claude.